I pick up my phone, dial the number and hit ‘Talk.’
It’s the week before my first Christmas, and I’m more anxious than Sarah Jessica Parker at the Kentucky Derby.
So many horses. One of them has to be my father!
I want to get my girlfriend something special, but before I buy it, I need to find out what the rest of her family got her.
Only, there’s a slight problem.
I don’t know if my girlfriend’s family still acknowledges Santa Clause’s existence, and I don’t want to be rude by assuming they know he’s not real.
The phone stops ringing, and my girlfriend’s mom picks up.
We chat awkwardly for a few moments, then I get to the heart of why I’ve called.
“So … uh…,” I begin confidently. “You wouldn’t happen to know what Santa’s leaving your daughter under the Christmas tree, would you?”
There’s a pause.
“Are you kidding me?” her mom answers. “This is a joke, right? Of course I know. I’m her mother! I bought those damn gifts. You really think there’s a Santa? … Wait, Jeff, will you hold on a sec? I’ve got the other line. It’s the ‘Easter Bunny’ …”
“Well, all right,” I say, annoyed. “But could you ask him for some gift ideas?”
“You’re an idiot,” she says.
***
My girlfriend and I are blessed. For many reasons. We love each other, we have a healthy baby, and we never have to worry about the toilet seat being left up because we both pee sitting down.
But there’s still one giant elephant in the room that neither of us wants to discuss: Religion.
See, she was born Methodist. And I was born with shoulder hair. Or in other words, a Jew.
Though both of us come from strong religious backgrounds, neither of us currently practice. In fact, if religion were a sport, I’d be Allen Iverson.
“We’re talking about practice?! Practice?! … I mean listen, we’re sitting here talking about practice! Not a game, not a game, not a game, but we’re talking about practice, man!”
But even though we’re both secular, we’ve decided that we want our daughter to grow up with a religion.
Brooklyn and her mommy on Christmas Eve.
We just don’t know which one.
“How about we explain the core beliefs of each faith, and then let Brooklyn decide for herself?” my girlfriend once suggested.
“That’s not a bad idea,” I had replied.
Then I began to imagine:
It’d be just like The Practice. Brooklyn would be the judge, and my girlfriend and I would be the attorneys, debating for hours before giving our closing arguments.
My girlfriend would be like, “Your Honor. If you choose Christianity, you’ll get to believe in Jesus, the son of God who died for your sins. You’ll get to celebrate Christmas, where you’ll get to decorate a giant tree and put up beautiful Christmas lights. You’ll sing about Rudolph and Donor and Blitzen, and you’ll get to open tons of wonderful presents that were given to you by Santa Claus, the jolliest man on Earth. Plus, you’ll be a member of the most popular religion in the world.”
Then I’d be like, “Your Honor. If you choose Judaism, you won’t get any of that. No Jesus, no Santa Clause, no reindeer. In fact, most of the world will probably hate you. But … when you grow up … you have a 99 percent chance of being really f-cking rich!”
My girlfriend would be like, “I object! I obj –”
Then Brooklyn would pound the gavel. “Order, order, order! I’ve come to a decision … Someone get this girl a yamakah!”
***
It’s Christmas Eve. I, along with the rest of my girlfriend’s family, sit two rows from the back of the biggest church I’ve ever seen.
I feel like I’m at Kauffman Stadium; I need binoculars just to see the action. The only difference is that this place is actually full.
“Maybe if the Royals invested less time in Luke Hochevar and more time in Jesus, they’d actually have some believers,” I tell my girlfriend.
“Shhhh,” she says. “The service is about to begin.”
After a few minutes of gripping announcements — the Jump Rope for Jesus on Thursday sounds like a whale of a time — the Pastor leads the congregation in prayer.
I join in, screaming at the top of my lungs.
“HARK, THE HERALD ANGELS SING! GLORY TO A NEW BORN KING!”
The church members all turn and stare at me.
“What are you doing?!” my girlfriend whispers.
“We’re sitting in the nosebleeds,” I answer. “If I’m going to do this, I want to make sure Jesus can hear me!”
***
It’s Christmas morning.
My girlfriend, my baby and I all arrive at my girlfriend’s mom’s house.
Why go to church to read about angels when I’ve got my own right here?
It’s early. Too early. I’m used to celebrating Hanukkah, which takes place during the night.
“I don’t care how great Christmas is,” I tell my girlfriend as I ring the doorbell. “No holiday is worth celebrating at 7 a.m.”
“What’s your deal?” my girlfriend asks.
“I don’t do mornings!” I say. “I do nights. Date nights. Late nights. Put me in front of a live studio audience and I’ll say, ‘Ittt’s Saturday Night!’ BUT I DO NOT DO MORNINGS!”
Her mom opens the door.
“Merry Christmas!” she exclaims.
“Merry Christmas!” I reply. “Which way to the eggnog?”
***
After getting settled in and sufficiently tipsy, I join everyone in the family room. It’s packed. There’s almost as many people as there are gifts under the tree.
As I look around, I feel like I stick out like a — well, like a Jew on Christmas morning.
To the left of the tree sit my girlfriend’s mom and my girlfriend’s younger sister. To the right sit my girlfriend’s older sister and her husband, along with her husband’s parents. Behind us sit my girlfriend’s grandparents, who drove all the way from North Carolina to be here for Brooklyn’s first Christmas.
“I’m sure you’re used to all this, Jeff,” my girlfriend’s older sister says. “Hanukkah’s eight crazy nights, right?”
“Not really,” I say. “It’s more like two nights of disappointment followed by six nights of who gives a crap.”
The gift opening ensues, and it rages on forever. Gift after gift. Picture after picture. Hug after hug.
Brooklyn with her brown, hairy bear. And a new stuffed animal!
And every gift that is opened is received with a variation of the same reaction.
“O.M.G. That is so cute!” Or, “That’s really cute!” Or, “That’s so stinkin’ cute!”
“I think I’m going to vomit,” I whisper to Brooklyn.
Then I look at her spit-stained dress.
“Looks like you’re one step ahead of me,” I say.
A few gifts later, my girlfriend’s mom hands me a small present.
“This one’s for Brooklyn, from her cousins in Carolina.”
I open it up, and it appears to be a small metal dumbbell with Brooklyn’s monogram engraved on it.
My face turns red with anger.
“What is this?!” I ask. “Why would someone give a dumbbell to a baby? I know she’s got some extra fat, but good God! She’s a baby! What else did her cousins get her? A treadmill and a Nike calorie counter so she can see how much weight she loses every time she takes a dump?! This is outrageous!”
The whole room draws quiet.
“It’s not a dumbbell,” my girlfriend says. “It’s a rattle!”
Then she shakes it.
“See!” she says.
“Oh … M. G!” I say. “That is so stinkin’ cute!”
***
It’s 1 p.m. Time for an intermission. Or as Jewish people like to call it, “lunch.”
We all walk into the kitchen, and there’s food as far as the eye can see.
There’s corn bread and salad and mashed potatoes and sweet potatoes and cranberries and six — six! — different kinds of casserole. At the end of the line there’s two different large trays. One is filled with turkey, the other with ham.
“Why aren’t you getting any ham, young man?” my girlfriend’s grandpa grumbles.
“Because Jewish people aren’t allowed to eat pork products,” I tell him.
He looks back at me with wild, enraged eyes, like it was 1941 again, and I had just broken the news about Pearl Harbor.
“DEAR MOTHER OF MOSES!” he yells. “IT CAN’T BE TRUE!”
“Unfortunately it is,” I say.
“I don’t get it,” he replies. “Why the hell can’t Jews eat the greatest animal on God’s green earth? Aren’t you supposed to be ‘The Chosen’ people?”
“We are,” I respond. “We’re the ones God ‘chose’ to make miserable.”
As we finish eating, my girlfriend’s mom comes up to my girlfriend and me and hands us the wish bone.
I was like, “I’ma break you in two, wishbone!” And the wishbone was all like, “Awww snap!”
“As new parents, you two get the honor of breaking the wish bone,” she announces. “The goal is to make the same wish. It should be something important. Something that means a lot to the both of you. Something like happiness, or success or great health.”
I look at my girlfriend. She looks back at me. Then we both look at our baby. It’s like we can read each other’s minds. Even though we haven’t said a word, I know in my heart we’re both wishing for the same thing.
“Ready … Go!” my girlfriend’s mom screams.
We start pulling the wishbone, twisting it with all our might until it finally breaks.
The bone snaps, and I end up with the larger piece.
“I win!” I exclaim. “I win!”
Then I look around the room, searching to see if my wish was granted.
“Where’s the iPad?!” I yell. “Does somebody see an iPad?!”
“That’s what you wished for?” my girlfriend asks.
“Well, duh!” I say. “Now where is it? Could you lift up the baby? She’s probably sitting on it. I can’t wait to download 50 Shades of Grey!”
***
The sun is setting. Christmas is almost over.
My girlfriend’s mom just opened a gift from us, even though she insisted she didn’t want anything.
“This beautiful baby is my gift,” she says.
“No it’s not,” I protest. “If the baby were a gift, I would have exchanged her for a different color.”
“What?” my girlfriend’s mom asks.
“I’m just saying,” I continue, “that baby’s are like iPhones. Everyone wants a black one.”
“Not me!” my girlfriend’s grandpa yells.
Then I give my girlfriend her gift from me.
“I know how much you’ve been through this past month,” I say. “So I wanted to give you something I knew you’d enjoy.”
She opens it up.
It’s a gift certificate for a full spa treatment at a nearby salon.
“I love it!” my girlfriend says.
“I’m so glad,” I say. “I bought the ‘John Travolta’ package, so everything’s included.”
“This is exactly what I needed,” she says. “Thank you so much!”
“You’re welcome,” I say. “But don’t thank me. Thank the Easter Bunny.”